Apr 3, 2017
A medical student in the emergency department at a busy public hospital sees a patient who has been in a fight. His x-ray is pretty impressive; all five fingers are shattered. After taking a photo of the x-ray on his smartphone he proudly shows some of his friends at a BBQ the next day. The x-ray includes the patient’s name and date of birth. Is this a good idea?
Clinical images and smarter alternatives
There are numerous laws, regulations and policies that govern how personal and sensitive health information can be collected, disclosed, stored and secured. While the law does not specifically preclude using smartphones to capture clinical images, there are some particular issues with using personal phones that mean it may be preferable to have a camera or phone that belongs to the workplace if you are taking images regularly.
There are certain procedures and processes you need to follow to ensure a patient’s privacy and confidentiality is not breached in the context of clinical images. Working in a hospital, you also need to follow any relevant hospital policies that cover the use of smartphones.
Depending on the circumstances, use of clinical images by doctors may be regulated by the Commonwealth Privacy Act 1988 (the Privacy Act), state-based health records and privacy legislation, the Australian Medical Board Advertising Guidelines, and the Australian Medical Board’s Good Medical Practice: A Code of Conduct for Doctors in Australia.
In the scenario above, the medical student took a photograph of the x-ray because it was unusual – it was not taken for the purposes of providing care. What did the student intend to do with the image, and did they discuss it with the patient?
When taking a clinical image, you need to obtain the patient’s consent, and explain to the patient the purpose of taking the photograph, how you intend to use it, and who is likely to see it.
What if you can’t identify the patient in the image? If the image is de-identified and does not include any personal information the privacy legislation doesn’t apply. You do, however, need to ensure it’s completely de-identified – the rare or unique characteristics that you are interested in may be identifying features.
What else should you do?
Record patient consent
Document the patient’s verbal consent relating to the clinical photograph in the patient’s medical record, or check if your workplace requires written consent. You should also check any other relevant policies to guide you in how you use clinical images. Check out our factsheet ‘Consent essentials’.
Secure the image
Take reasonable steps to prevent any unauthorised access to the image. For example, security codes, passwords, and remote erasing capability are likely to be considered reasonable steps. Disable any automatic processes that would upload images to a social network or back-up sites.
Add the image to the patient’s file
As soon as possible, the image should be incorporated into the patient’s medical record, with a note about the consultation and diagnosis. Then it should be immediately deleted from the mobile device.
What would be appropriate?
It’s okay to use a clinical image to facilitate treatment for a patient and to help with their clinical management. It may also be appropriate to use clinical images and other information for writing case reports and educative purposes, if the patient provides their specific consent for this purpose.
Showing friends at a BBQ a patient’s impressive x-ray with or without their consent? This is always unprofessional.
- Clinical images, including photographs taken on your personal smartphone, form part of the medical record and are subject to the same requirements as all other parts of the medical record.
- Make sure you have the patient’s consent to capture a clinical image and their consent is documented in the medical record.
- If using your personal smartphone, ensure the image is uploaded into the hospital record and then securely delete the image from your phone.
- You should review the practice or hospital protocols to understand what the policy is at your practice or hospital.
- If using your personal smartphone, carefully consider your settings to make sure you protect it with strong security settings such as passwords.
- Do not post clinical photographs to social media or share them in ways not contemplated in the consent process, regardless of privacy settings.
For further advice visit:
Avant’s frequently asked questions Mobile technology and digital photography. The AMA and MIIAA Clinical Images and the use of personal mobile device: A guide for medical students and doctors.
Read a related article by Josephine Montgomery on clinical images and smartphones that recently appeared in Medical Observer.